Every Sunday as a kid, Jeni would beeline for the dessert table at her church potluck (all good Midwesterners love any excuse for food and community). Texas Sheet Cake, the one-inch high, double chocolate cake, was always part of the spread. Though the history of this cake’s name is a little murky—it’s a fitting moniker for something so big and rich.

Our rendition is a chocolate triple down with mouth-filling, Fair Trade cocoa, crumbly chocolate cake pieces, and a river of bittersweet chocolate fudge. Forget that this flavor is dairy-free. It’s as good as, if not better than, everything else we make.